Homemade Marshmallows With Simple Ingredients

Homemade Marshmallows With Simple Ingredients

Homemade marshmallows take about 20 minutes of hands on time and a short list of ingredients you can actually pronounce. No corn syrup, no artificial flavors, no dyes. Just sugar, water, gelatin, vanilla, and a pinch of salt.

This is a fun one to make with kids around the holidays. They love watching the mixture puff up in the mixer, and a mug of hot chocolate with a homemade marshmallow on top feels like a real treat.

This is still candy. It is sugar, and I treat it like a special occasion food. What I like about making it at home is knowing exactly what went into the pan.

Why make marshmallows from scratch

Most bagged marshmallows are made with corn syrup and artificial flavor, and some colored varieties use synthetic dyes. Making a batch at home lets you choose every ingredient, from the type of sugar to the gelatin.

The recipe is also forgiving. You do not need special skills. A stand mixer does most of the work.

What you need

Ingredients

  • 1 cup cold water, divided

  • 5.5 teaspoons beef gelatin (I use Aspen Naturals)

  • 2 cups organic cane sugar, or 1 cup cane sugar and 1 cup organic maple sugar

  • 1 vanilla bean, optional (I use Laie Vanilla Company)

  • A pinch of sea salt (I use Vera Salt)

  • Coconut oil for greasing the dish (I use Dr. Bronner's)

  • Organic powdered sugar for dusting

Tools

  • Stand mixer with the whisk attachment

  • Medium pot

  • Glass baking dish

  • Fine mesh sifter

  • Spatula and a metal spoon

  • Candy thermometer, optional

How to make homemade marshmallows

  1. Bloom the gelatin. Pour 1/2 cup of cold water into the bowl of a stand mixer. Sprinkle 5.5 teaspoons of gelatin over the top. Do not stir. Let it sit until the gelatin has absorbed all of the water.

  2. Add the vanilla. If you are using a vanilla bean, slice it down the middle and scrape out the seeds with the back of a knife. Add the seeds to the bowl with the gelatin.

  3. Combine the sugar and water. Pour the other 1/2 cup of cold water into a pot and add 2 cups of sugar. You can use all cane sugar, or half cane and half maple. Wait for the sugar to absorb the water.

  4. Heat the sugar. Warm the pot over medium heat until every granule has dissolved. The mixture will bubble and turn clear around the sides. Dip a spoon in to check that you cannot feel any grains. Do not let it burn.

  5. Prep the dish. While the sugar heats, coat a glass baking dish with coconut oil, including the sides. Sift powdered sugar over the whole dish, sides included.

  6. Start the mixer. Add the salt to the gelatin and turn the mixer on low.

  7. Pour in the syrup. Once the sugar has fully dissolved, slowly pour the hot syrup into the mixing bowl while you gradually increase the speed.

  8. Whip. Keep the mixer on high for about 10 minutes. The mixture should double in size and look like meringue.

  9. Transfer. Use a spatula to scrape the marshmallow into the prepared dish.

  10. Smooth the top. Run a spoon under hot water and use the back of it to spread the marshmallow evenly.

  11. Dust. Sift more powdered sugar over the top.

Let the pan cool completely, then slice into squares.

Tips for getting them right

  • Let the gelatin bloom fully. Stirring too early leaves dry clumps that never dissolve.

  • Trust the spoon test. If you can still feel sugar granules, keep heating. Undissolved sugar makes gritty marshmallows.

  • Using a candy thermometer? Classic marshmallow recipes cook the syrup to about 240°F at sea level. Subtract roughly 2°F for every 1,000 feet of elevation, since water boils at a lower temperature in the mountains.

  • Pour slowly. Hot sugar syrup can cause serious burns. Keep little hands away from the stove and the mixer for this step, and bring the kids back in for the whipping and dusting.

  • Work quickly at the end. The marshmallow starts to set as soon as the mixer stops, so have the dish ready before you whip.

  • Slice with a greased knife. A little coconut oil on the blade keeps it from sticking. Toss the cut edges in powdered sugar.

How to store and serve them

Homemade marshmallows last 3 to 5 days. Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature.

A few ways to enjoy them:

  • Dropped into a mug of hot chocolate

  • Toasted over a fire for s'mores

  • Packed in a jar with a ribbon as a homemade holiday gift

  • Eaten straight from the pan, which is how most of them disappear here

If you make a batch, tag @dr.organicmommy so I can see how they turned out.